Dashboard
Warning Lights

The Cars Original Owners Keep the Longest

Editor's note: This list is based on published studies, manufacturer specifications and public records from the sources named in the article. It is not a rating of any individual car. More

Figures change with model year, trim and location, and the studies are updated every year, so check the current data and your own vehicle before you buy, sell or repair. The author has not tested every vehicle discussed. Most photos are credited Wikimedia Commons images and may show a different model year or trim; any marked for illustration are AI-generated.

Most people trade in a car long before it turns 15. Of the cars that reach that age, the best 15-year-olds are still with the person who bought them new more than twice as often as the average, 13.7% against 6.1%.

This is an iSeeCars study of cars sold in 2020, covering model years 1981 to 2005, so it counts the older cars. Below, 18 models count down from the least loyal owners to the most.

18. Honda Civic: Barely above average, with a loyal streak

Maroon 2003 Honda Civic LX sedan seventh generation parked beside a lawn, front three-quarter view
Photo: Elise240SX / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Start with how the study works. iSeeCars looked at more than 660,000 cars from the 1981 to 2005 model years that were sold in 2020. It estimated what share of each model’s 15-year-old-plus cars were sold by the person who bought them new.

The overall average was 6.1%. The Civic comes in at 6.7%, about 1.1 times that. This is about how long people keep a car, not how many miles it can reach.

The 18 here are the best-known models in the study’s tables, in the study’s order. Four others sit between them and are not profiled: Acura MDX (7.9%), GMC Canyon (7.8%), Hyundai Tucson (7.6%) and Chevrolet Colorado (7.6%).

If you own a 2001 to 2005 Civic, check your VIN at NHTSA. Honda’s 2015 driver air bag inflator recall covers those years, and you pay nothing for the fix.

Keep the recall letter if you have one, and your service records too. A future buyer may want to see both.

17. Subaru Outback: Short of the Forester, still above average

Red 2003 Subaru Outback wagon third generation parked on a brick driveway, front three-quarter view
Photo: OSX / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Outback holds 6.8% in the same study, 1.1 times the average. That puts it a hair ahead of the Civic and well behind its smaller sibling.

If yours spent its life on salted roads, look underneath it. A 2003 NHTSA notice names Legacy and Outback models from 2000 to 2003 whose rear subframe paint was poor enough that road salt could eat through the part.

Subaru’s fix was a free clean and rustproof at the dealer. You can ask a shop to check the same area on any Outback of that age.

Rust is the common enemy of an older car in the snow belt. Ask your mechanic to put it on the lift and look, because you cannot see it from above.

16. Honda Accord: Sold by the million, and a lot of owners stayed

Silver 2003 Honda Accord seventh generation sedan parked outdoors, side view
Photo: Enrique Alonso Espinoza Sanchez / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

The Accord scores 7.2% in the study, 1.2 times the average. With so many sold, even a modest share adds up to a great many long-term owners.

If you drive a 2003 to 2007 Accord V6, there is one item for your list. A 2012 NHTSA recall found that the power steering hose could break down early and leak fluid onto a hot catalytic converter.

Honda’s remedy was a new heat-resistant hose, free of charge. Ask your dealer whether yours was done.

The study cannot tell you why each owner stayed. It shows only that, for the Accord, more of them did than for the average car.

15. Mazda MX-5 Miata: The sports car people refuse to sell

Silver 2003 Mazda MX-5 Miata second generation roadster parked, front three-quarter view
Photo: Elise240SX / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The Miata is the one sports car on this list, and its 7.6% nearly doubles the 4.1% sports-car average in the study. Wikipedia’s MX-5 entry calls it the best-selling two-seat convertible sports car in history.

A 2005 automatic is rated 22 mpg combined by the EPA, so you buy it for fun and not for thrift.

If you own a 2001 to 2005 Miata, type your VIN into NHTSA’s recall lookup. It takes a minute and shows any open campaign on your car.

For a buyer, the numbers say these owners tend to keep theirs. That makes a well-kept one hard to find.

14. Nissan Frontier: A small truck that earned its keepers

White 2003 Nissan Frontier crew cab pickup parked, front three-quarter view
Photo: Ethan Llamas / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The Frontier ties the Camry at 8.5%, about 1.4 times the average. Among light pickups in the study it ranks third, behind the Tacoma and the Tundra.

If you own a 2002 to 2004, ask about Nissan’s steering column recall. Corrosion could form in the lower steering column joint, and Nissan replaced the shaft and joint with a new design.

A dealer can run your VIN in a minute. The repair was free.

The Frontier’s study rank is for the years up to 2005 only. Newer Frontiers are a different truck, and you should not read this figure onto them.

13. Toyota Camry: The sedan your neighbor never traded in

Silver 2004 Toyota Camry LE sedan parked in a lot, front three-quarter view
Photo: MercurySable99 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The Camry also lands at 8.5%, tied with the Frontier. It is one of the best-selling models in the study, so plenty of owners had the chance to keep one.

Do you have a 2004 or 2005 V6? Toyota’s 2011 recall notice covers certain ones built from June 2004 to March 2005, where a crankshaft pulley could come apart and let the power steering belt slip off.

Dealers replaced the pulley when needed, at no cost to you.

Every Camry in the study is at least 15 years old by now. At that age you should keep a log of what has been replaced and when.

12. Toyota RAV4: Early ones are still around, with one repair to check

Silver 2004 to 2005 Toyota RAV4 second generation SUV parked, front three-quarter view
Photo: IFCAR / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The RAV4 reaches 8.7%, 1.4 times the average. The study covers its earliest years, from the 1990s to 2005.

Check the build date on yours. In 2015, Toyota recalled 2004 and 2005 RAV4s built from May 2003 to October 2005 because the driver air bag inflator could rupture. The notice told owners not to drive the vehicle until the repair was done.

If you are unsure it was done, call a Toyota dealer first. Our RAV4 tips guide is written for newer models.

Your build date matters here, because the recall covers a set range. It is printed on the sticker inside the driver’s door jamb.

11. Toyota Corolla: The plain choice you stay with

Silver 2003 to 2004 Toyota Corolla sedan parked on a street, front three-quarter view
Photo: IFCAR / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Corolla scores 8.9%, 1.5 times the average, and it is the least flashy car on this list.

Do you have a 2003 or 2004? In 2008, Toyota recalled 662,178 Corollas, Corolla Matrixes and Pontiac Vibes because the door glass bolts could loosen and the glass could separate from its regulator.

Dealers fitted new bolts for free. If your windows rattle, that is the reason to ask.

A Corolla with 15 years on it is worth keeping only if it has been looked after. You can check that from the receipts in your glovebox.

10. Toyota Sequoia: The big SUV that stays in the family

Gray 2001 to 2003 Toyota Sequoia first generation SUV parked in a lot, front three-quarter view
Photo: IFCAR / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Sequoia holds 9.1%, or 1.5 times the average, and it sits in the study’s top ten. iSeeCars’ 2026 study also named it the most likely car to reach 250,000 miles, at 42.3%.

That is a different measure from this list, but the two point the same way.

If yours is a 2003, ask a dealer whether the 2010 stability control reflash was done. Toyota said the system could activate for a few seconds on takeoff and slow your acceleration, and the update was free.

The study measures how long owners kept the vehicle, not what it cost them. Your own fuel and insurance bills are the better guide to whether yours is worth keeping.

9. Toyota 4Runner: Rugged, familiar, and hard to give up

Red 2005 Toyota 4Runner SR5 Sport fourth generation SUV parked, front three-quarter view
Photo: HJUdall / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

The 4Runner reaches 9.4%, 1.5 times the average, which puts it ninth overall. It is also fifth on the study’s list of best-selling models.

Look at your floor mat. A 2011 Toyota recall covers 2003 to 2009 4Runners, where an unsecured or wrong-size driver’s mat could trap the accelerator pedal.

The remedy was a modified pedal and a replacement all-weather mat. Use only mats made for your vehicle, and keep them clipped in.

If you have towed with yours or used it off pavement, tell your mechanic. Your records matter more to its next 100,000 miles than the odometer does.

8. Subaru Forester: The wagon-like SUV that keeps its fans

Silver 2004 Subaru Forester second generation wagon parked, front three-quarter view
Photo: No machine-readable author provided. Sfoskett~commonswiki assumed (based on copyright claims). / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

The Forester gets 9.8%, 1.6 times the average. It is the only Subaru in the study’s top ten.

If you live where roads are salted, check the front lower control arms. NHTSA’s 2011 Subaru notice covers 2003 to 2008 Foresters in those states, where the arms could rust and break at their brackets.

Subaru inspected them and either rustproofed or replaced the arms at no charge. Our Forester tips guide covers newer features.

The Forester gets credit in the study for staying put. Your own car’s rust check takes ten minutes and can save you a bigger bill later.

7. Honda Pilot: The family hauler that never left the driveway

Tan 2003 to 2005 Honda Pilot SUV parked in a lot, front three-quarter view
Photo: IFCAR / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Pilot scores 10.4%, 1.7 times the average. The study’s model years stop at 2005, so you are looking at the first-generation Pilot, built from 2003.

A 2012 Honda recall covers 2003 and 2004 models. The ignition switch interlock lever could deform, which would let you remove the key without shifting into park, and the vehicle could roll away.

Honda installed an updated lever for free. Until then, set the parking brake and shift into park every time.

If anyone else in your household drives yours, make sure they know the recall work was done. A dealer can confirm it from your VIN.

6. Honda CR-V: The small SUV with the most settled owners

Blue 2003 Honda CR-V LX second generation SUV parked outdoors, front three-quarter view
Photo: order_242 from Chile / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

The CR-V scores 10.7%, 1.8 times the average, and it is the top Honda in the study.

In 2020, Honda recalled 2002 to 2006 CR-Vs because moisture could get into the driver’s window master switch. A failed switch could overheat and smoke.

Dealers replaced the switch and checked the wiring harness for free. Our CR-V controls guide shows what newer models can do.

The Pilot comes close at 10.4%, but no other Honda gets past the CR-V. If you have not had the window switch checked, ask a Honda dealer.

5. Toyota Tundra: The full-size truck owners rarely sell

Gray 2003 to 2006 Toyota Tundra StepSide Access Cab pickup parked, front three-quarter view
Photo: IFCAR / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Tundra reaches 11.3%, 1.8 times the average, and it beats the domestic full-size pickups in the study by a wide margin. The F-150 sits at 5.1%, the Silverado 1500 at 6.0%.

If yours is a 2003 to 2005, check the passenger air bag recall. A 2018 NHTSA filing covers certain inflators that could explode from propellant degradation and send metal fragments into the cabin.

Toyota replaced the inflator or the whole air bag, and it costs you nothing.

A high rank does not mean every Tundra is perfect. Your own VIN lookup is how you find out about yours.

4. Toyota Sienna: The minivan owners will not give up

White 2004 to 2005 Toyota Sienna LE minivan parked on a street, front three-quarter view
Photo: IFCAR / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Sienna reaches 11.5%, 1.9 times the average. It is the only minivan in the study’s top ten.

The thing to look at is under the van. A 2014 NHTSA recall covers 2004 to 2011 Siennas in 20 salt-road states and Washington, D.C., where the spare tire cable could corrode and let the tire drop.

Toyota’s interim fix was to move the spare into the cargo area, at no cost to you. Check your VIN before the next winter.

If you still have yours, you are in a group the study can count. Look at the cable and the carrier before the next salted winter.

3. Toyota Tacoma: The pickup people hold on to

Red 2001 to 2004 Toyota Tacoma double cab pickup parked on a street, front three-quarter view
Photo: Bull-Doser / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Tacoma lands at 11.6%, 1.9 times the average. Among light pickups in the study, nothing beats it.

If you have a 2001 to 2004 truck from a road-salt state, ask a dealer about the spare tire. A 2012 Toyota recall covers those trucks, where the spare tire carrier’s lift plate could corrode.

Dealers inspected the carrier and replaced the lift plate when needed, free of charge. Our Tacoma tips guide covers newer trucks.

If your Tacoma has lived near salted roads, a mechanic can look at the spare tire carrier in a few minutes. Ask for it at your next oil change.

2. Toyota Highlander: Twice the average, from a top seller

Silver Toyota Highlander 2004 to 2007 SUV parked in a lot, front three-quarter view
Photo: IFCAR / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

At 12.4%, the Highlander is twice the 6.1% average. It is also the top model on the study’s list of popular US vehicles, the best-sellers.

Toyota’s 2011 accelerator recall covers 2004 to 2006 Highlanders. If the floor carpet cover clip was not installed properly, the cover could lean on the pedal and keep it from returning to idle.

Toyota replaced the cover with a new design for free. See our Highlander guide for newer features.

A twice-average result is rare. If you have owned yours since new, you are part of the reason the number is so high.

1. Toyota Prius: The owners who never let go

Silver Toyota Prius second generation 2004 to 2007 hybrid hatchback, front three-quarter view
Photo: IFCAR / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

The Prius takes first place at 13.7%, 2.2 times the average. No other model in the study beats it.

The study’s Prius cars are the 2001 to 2005 years. The EPA rates a 2004 at 46 mpg combined, which still looks good today.

Two 2012 NHTSA recalls cover 2004 to 2009 Prius models, one for a steering shaft and one for an electric water pump. Both repairs were free.

A fair word on the numbers. Every percentage on this page comes from the study of cars sold in 2020, and a model’s rank can shift with the year.

iSeeCars ran a newer study in October 2024. Motor1 reports it covered 929,000 cars from 1981 to 2009 sold that year, with a lower 3.7% average and only 13 models ranked.

Toyota again took the top five places, with the Highlander Hybrid first at 7.0% and the Prius fifth at 6.3%. Auto Remarketing confirms the 7.0% and the average. That is why this list uses the older study: it ranks far more models.

Read more: What Older Toyota Trucks Got Right About Everyday Ownership

Sources
Image sources and credits